‘This carelessly drafted scrap of legislative sophistry’ – more SNP incompetence

For reasons that may or may not be obvious, I rarely write about sport or sectarianism. Life is short, they are subjects I have little interest in, and by and large writing about them causes more trouble than it’s worth. On the other hand, and more often than you might think, you could flick through the pages of this blog and find positive comments about individual nationalists – when they say something that makes sense.

Today’s post is a rare occasion when I respond to all these things I found in one place – a radio piece by nationalist-leaning journalist Kevin McKenna, who usually writes for The Herald and the separatists’ in-house tabloid, The National. Yesterday, he had a five-minute slot on the new-ish BBC Radio 4 programme From our Home Correspondent. His subject was the history of the rivalry between Rangers and Celtic football clubs and ‘what it tells us about Glasgow today’ (it starts at 11:29 on the recording linked above – it’ll probably disappear from the BBC website after a few weeks).

Here is part of what McKenna said:

In 2012 the Scottish Government decided to rid the country of what it called ‘Scotland’s shame’ when it passed the Offensive Behaviour at Football Act. This carelessly drafted scrap of legislative sophistry made global legal history by creating a virtual crime. This is because a fellow can be charged with espousing sentiments deemed to be offensive even when no-one is present to be offended. All over the country and especially in West Central Scotland fans with no previous convictions have experienced dawn raids by police. In 2013 sheriff Richard Davidson described the Act as ‘mince’ adding, ‘If they can prescribe a list of songs which people are banned from singing they will find the courts are full and the grounds empty.’ The sheriff was right. Cracking down on sectarian behaviour in such a way is simplistic and illiberal. What is harder is delivering these communities from their real ills – poverty, squalor and disease, and homelessness.

I make no apology for the extended quote. It’s pretty damning.

In 2011 the SNP, having formed a minority government for the previous four years, gained an absolute majority in the Scottish parliament. This ‘carelessly drafted scrap of legislative sophistry … simplistic and illiberal … mince,’ was one of their early priorities. It joins a long list of policies over nearly ten years where their actions have been ineffective.

Earlier in his piece, McKenna listed what he saw as the causes of the ‘real ills’ in these communities – ‘[poor] health, educational inequality, unemployment, alcoholism and crime.’

Ask yourself which of those things the Scottish parliament is responsible for or has a major influence over. How about all of them? If you want to see a shocking example of some of the worst conditions that people in these communities have to put up with after ten years of SNP government, look no further than the Facebook Let’s save Govanhill page. Govanhill is in the constituency of which MSP? Correct, Nicola Sturgeon.

You might wish to consider the true nature of ‘Scotland’s shame.’

Footnote: As always, I’m happy to publish comments on what I write but don’t expect me to engage in discussion on football or sectarianism.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to ‘This carelessly drafted scrap of legislative sophistry’ – more SNP incompetence

  1. Football fans accused of behaviour that in the context of Scottish football is clearly sectarian often excuse themselves on the grounds that we are political but the other lot are sectarian. This act appears to have been an attempt to deal with this, but it could work only if the police, judges and juries were capable of mind reading.

    The SNP’s answer to every problem in Scotland is independence. It therefore has little interest in dealing with major social issues before independence. Trying and succeeding might lead to people deciding that the current system works. Trying and failing might might cost it the next election. Either would prevent it achieving its goal. Far better to pose for selfies, pontificate about issues outside its areas of responsibility and blame everything on ‘Wastemonster.’

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s