‘Scotland’s a very different place now’

I heard this claim in a TV news report during the aftermath of Thursday’s general election. The SNP, in case you’ve just woken from your winter hibernation, increased their number of MPs from six to 56 out of 59. Even this old curmudgeon and unionist ‘nawbag’ (© 2015 Pete Wishart MP)  would have to concede it was a famous victory.

But does it mean Scotland’s that different from the rest of the UK, as the TV news report was saying?

If you want real difference, head for Northern Ireland, although even in those special circumstances you won’t feel as different as if you’d pitched up in, say, Baku, or Madrid, or even Dublin.

As for the rest of it – surprise, surprise – it’s very similar.

The people are walking the same sorts of streets, eating and drinking mostly the same things, concerned about the same day to day issues. They’re driving on the same roads that have the same dodgy surfaces off the main drags, they’re waiting the same long times to get a routine GP appointment (my record in Aberdeen is two weeks) in an NHS that is essentially the same across the UK. Almost everything feels the same.

It feels the same unless of course you’re looking for difference. And as I’ve pointed out before, that is one of the nationalist’s key tools – to highlight and exaggerate differences where they exist, to create them where they don’t, and then to say, ‘Ooh look, we’re different. We should be separate.’

In truth, the differences between Scotland and the rest of the UK are more points of party political policy than anything inherently ‘national.’ In Scotland, many are the sort of things that a UK government of a slightly different hue might have done – ‘free’ prescriptions, the abolition of bridge tolls and university tuition fees, building a major new road bridge.

Interestingly all these populist, and easy, things were committed during the SNP government’s first, minority, term. Their major actions since have been less universally greeted with joy – the creation of single national police and fire & rescue services, the rationalisation of FE colleges and funding, the named person legislation for children, the proposed sharing of NHS personal data across and outside government. None of these are in any way ‘progressive’ in a true sense, despite the left(ish) wing mantle the SNP claim to have clothed themselves in after they dragged it off what currently looks like the rump of the Scottish Labour party.

Anyhow, as the rare passing nationalist might note, I’m in danger of another anti-SNP rant (don’t worry, they’ll come over the next few months). My real point is that one about difference. Even in the urgency of post-election reporting as the political dust was settling it was disappointing to hear journalists repeat the separatist mantra that Scotland is now a very different place.

I do hope the Mhairi Blacks, the Natalie McGarreys and the rest of the rag tag and bobtail army of new SNP MPs that represent us for better or worse at Westminster, and in all truth may not have spent much time outside God’s own country, get out and about across England. It’d be a pity if they thought the much larger army of strangely-suited toffs across from them in the febrile atmosphere of the Commons chamber were all there is to England. They’d find that, take away the funny accents, the English are really just like us after all.

Which of course is another reason to stay together as one united country. And which doubtless will form part of the next existential battle – the Scottish parliamentary elections in 2016.

PS – I will be returning to the statistics of what I conceded was the SNP’s ‘famous’ general election victory soon, when it may appear it’s not quite as famous as nationalists might think.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to ‘Scotland’s a very different place now’

  1. Michael Perera says:

    No doubt this was a blow. One can hope it is peak SNP and a more focused concentration on their record between now and Holyrood elections will allow reason to enter the minds after the emotion fades.


  2. Graham Fraser says:

    We’ll need voices like yours now we live in a One Party State in Scotland – keep up the resistance to corrosive Nationalism – over half the population hasn’t yet become conned by the Cult of the SNP.


  3. I know very few Scots who have not been to London, but quite a lot who have otherwise travelled very little in England. I wonder if those who believe that England and Scotland are very different are assuming that the rest of England is like London.
    In fact, London is like nowhere else except perhaps New York. The UK does change the further that you get from London, but I contend that it is a gradual change. I do not believe that there is a point at which there is a step change, but if there is one, it is at a line drawn from the Wash to the Severn rather than at the Tweed.


    • Susan Smith says:

      My English brother in law feels as if he’s in. foreign country when he’s in Scorland – which is what I feel about England . By the way I lived in Wngland for the first 20 years of my life and had 3 English grandparents . England stopped being my country in about 1979.


      • Roger White says:

        Well I have to respect your understanding. Mine is different. When I go to England (Wales too over the last few years) I see people and lives that are very similar. In my view people (I’m not saying you) focus too much on politics and governments., which are both ephemeral.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.